Like anything health and fitness, what is trending has a major influence on how someone starting their journey structures their nutrition approach. When it comes to long term nutrition, two popular approaches often emerge: calorie counting and intuitive eating.
To me, it's interesting how full circle we have come to need to give an official title to what is simply eating but in the context of the many diets that have come and gone and controlled the mass of the population stuck in the mindset that they need to be smaller, intuitive eating seemingly becomes the 'anti diet' option for those fed up with giving so much of their headspace to what they eat everyday.
I think ultimately everyone should aim to be able to intuitively eat, to grow awareness of your body and it's nutritional needs and enough about whole foods to know how to structure your daily meals and respond to cravings.
Amongst many other ways that the idea of eating this way has been brought to light on social media in the fitness industry recently, Ive also witnessed a lot of comparison to the use of calorie counting and demonising this much more structured approach to dieting.
These strategies are frequently seen as opposites, with one emphasising structure and the other promoting freedom. However, this dichotomy misses the opportunity to see how both methods can coexist and complement each other in a woman’s journey toward eating well and in tune with her body.
Rather than pitting them against each other, I think it's important to understand how calorie counting can be used positively at different points in your journey.
Understanding Calorie Counting
Calorie counting involves tracking the calories you consume, often using apps or food diaries. It’s commonly used for weight management, athletic performance, or understanding food portions. While calorie counting is sometimes criticised for being overly rigid, their are certain circumstances where it can contribute to a more seamless progression towards ideal nutrition:
Awareness of Intake: Many women underestimate portion sizes or the caloric density of certain foods. Tracking calories can help build awareness of eating habits and identify areas for improvement. Having tracked data to reflect on helps us to understand how our body feels after certain foods and using our own experience to gather information about food. This trial and error has always seemed more effective amongst clients in creating lasting habits over education in other forms and simply being told what to do etc.
Educational Tool: Learning about macronutrients (carbohydrates, fats, and proteins) and their role in energy and health can be empowering. For example, women who aim to build muscle may need a better understanding of protein intake. In the same way, entering different foods into a tracking app can be a really time efficient way to understand how different processes effect the macronutrient profile of the foods we eat and help someone shift towards a more whole foods based diet.
Specific Goals: For women managing medical conditions (e.g., PCOS or diabetes), calorie counting can help maintain control over dietary choices to improve health outcomes. There are instances where weight loss is medical and will lessen symptoms, contribute to a specific outcome that will improve quality of life - tracking in these circumstances does not need to mean tracking irrationally and unhealthily entering a large deficit, but it can mean a more scientific approach when time is a factor to be considered.
Used in these positive ways, I absolutely think calorie counting is a tool that has a place in some women's journey towards holistic health. Like anything else however, this can quickly go wrong in a few different ways.
For women already susceptible to obsessive behaviour, including disordered eating - becoming too reliant on calorie counting can lead to negative attachment to your results at the end of the day. Attaching our value to how well we stuck to specific numbers often set in a generalised way that can often disregard circumstances that would change your bodies needs even daily. Using this method long term in many circumstances can lead to a negative relationship to food and eating bringing down enjoyment around social events that involve eating.
The Essence of Intuitive Eating
Intuitive eating focuses on tuning into your body’s natural hunger and fullness cues, rejecting external dieting rules. Made popular by dieticians Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch, this approach promotes a healthy relationship with food and encourages trust in your body. Here's why this method may appeal to the general population.
Freedom from Rules: Intuitive eating encourages listening to your cravings and honoring them without guilt. For instance, eating a piece of chocolate because you enjoy it, not because you “earned” it.
Mindfulness and Satisfaction: Intuitive eating often leads to greater awareness of what foods make you feel good, improving digestion and energy levels.
Healing Relationships with Food: For women recovering from disordered eating patterns or chronic dieting, intuitive eating can restore a sense of trust and self-compassion.
However, intuitive eating may be challenging for those unfamiliar with recognising hunger and fullness cues, especially after years of dieting.
Why These Approaches Are Complementary
Instead of framing calorie counting and intuitive eating as mutually exclusive, they can be seen as tools in a shared toolbox. Here’s how they complement one another:
Education Meets Intuition: Calorie counting can be a short-term tool to build foundational knowledge about nutrition. Once you’ve developed a sense of what your body needs, intuitive eating allows you to transition into a more sustainable, mindful approach. For example, knowing the energy density of foods can help you recognise when you’re intuitively choosing nutrient-dense options without needing to track.
Structure for Specific Goals: For women working toward specific fitness or medical goals, calorie counting can provide structure. Simultaneously, intuitive eating can help ensure that emotional needs are met and food is not reduced to mere numbers.
Building Long-Term Awareness: Many women struggle with understanding hunger and satiety cues after years of dieting. A period of calorie counting can teach portion awareness, while intuitive eating refines the ability to honour internal cues once this awareness is developed.
Balance Between Discipline and Flexibility: Calorie counting offers a disciplined framework when precision is needed (e.g., training for a marathon or managing a health condition). Intuitive eating adds flexibility, ensuring food choices remain joyful and not rigid.
Practical Steps to Integrate Both Approaches
Start with Education: Use calorie counting temporarily to understand your nutritional needs. Focus on macronutrients and portion sizes rather than aiming for perfection.
Transition Gradually: Begin practicing intuitive eating by tuning into your hunger and fullness signals during meals. Use your calorie-tracking knowledge as a guide, not a rulebook.
Honor Flexibility: Allow space for cravings and social meals without guilt. Balance days of mindful eating with days where calorie tracking might help you stay on track with specific goals.
Reflect Regularly: Journaling your experiences can help identify patterns, such as overeating when stressed or skipping meals when busy.
A Balanced Path to Wellness
By combining the structure of calorie counting with the mindfulness of intuitive eating, women can create a holistic approach to nutrition. Each method has its place and purpose, and together they can build a foundation for long-term health, self-awareness, and enjoyment of food.
The key is to use them as tools, not as rigid systems, allowing for flexibility, self-compassion, and personal growth on your health journey.
Nutrition is personal, and there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. Embracing the strengths of both calorie counting and intuitive eating allows women to craft a sustainable and fulfilling approach to their health goals. After all, food should nourish both the body and soul.
Comments